Countries and economic blocs across Africa are on a legislating spree to regulate the continent’s seed markets, ostensibly to overcome chronic hunger. The real reason, many believe, is the corporate push that is driving nations to facilitate and promote trade of hybrid seed varieties. The fear is that the new laws will destroy not only the continent’s food diversity, but also its indigenous practices of seed conservation.
A “$30,000 fine, or 20 years of imprisonment” — that is the punishment for trading uncertified or fake seeds in Malawi, laid down by its recent Seed Act.
Malawi government data estimates close to 60 per cent of seeds traded there as uncertified. The law, approved by the country’s parliament on April 4, provides for instruments to regulate the production, processing, certification, sale, import and export of seeds.
In a country where agriculture accounts for 80 per cent of the employment opportunities as well as 80 per cent of the total exports, the legislation was much needed. At least one would think so.
Its passage was preceded by nearly a decade of debate, with the approval to the Act stalled many times. The government deployed all reasons to justify the legislation, yet there is an uncomfortable question:
What happens to Malawi’s informal seed system, or farmer seed system?
It accounts for 80 per cent of planted seeds. That leaves only 20 per cent of ‘formal’ seeds to be regulated by the current law? Farmer groups and civil society organisations see the law as an entry of commercial seed companies to the market to ultimately take over the indigenous seed system.
The law had more advantages than disadvantages, Madalitso Kambauwa Wirima — Malawi’s deputy minister of agriculture — claimed at parliament April 4. But Ulemu Chilapondwa, vice-chairperson of the Parliamentary Committee on Agriculture and Food Security, offered a word of caution:
Multinational seed companies are overshadowing the domestic seed companies due to their resource advantage. This, therefore, calls for the government to put in place mechanisms that will protect the local seed companies.
John Lungu, chairperson of the Seed Traders Association of Malawi, raised the same concern:
The new law may result in loss of income and livelihood of farmers engaged by domestic seed companies to produce seeds. This is because most multinational companies engage farmers from their country of origin to produce the seeds for them.
Malawian farmers in recent years have experienced a gradual shift in the seeds sector: The improvised or high-yielding hybrid seeds from companies are replacing the farmer seed system.
Fifty-six year old Abraham Munthali of Mzuzu city in northern Malawi has been a farmer for more than 20 years. He told Down To Earth that hybrid seeds, traded in the formal market by companies and now being regulated by the government through the latest law, have taken over the traditional seeds in recent times:
I did not prefer hybrid seeds. But old varieties are vanishing fast from our farms. Some of these hybrid seeds sold by companies cannot be replanted. We have to buy seeds every year.
This has not been the case with the farmer seed system. For generations they have exchanged or traded indigenous seeds among themselves.
Rachel Wynberg, an associate professor with the University of Cape Town, attributes the change in the country’s agriculture scenario to a push for industrialisation: “Local varieties are increasingly unavailable because of neoliberal agricultural reforms that have subsidised fertilisers and hybrid seeds and promoted cash crops.”
Jacob Nyirenda, chief executive officer of the Farmers Union of Malawi (FUM), said:
There is fear that the new law will open up the domestic seed market to multinational companies. Domestic seed companies will be ultimately out of business. Along with it, the farmers’ own system of seed trade will die.
FUM is an umbrella organisation representing some 1.5 million farmers, commodity associations, traders, processors and producers. Tamani Nkhono Mvula, an agriculture policy expert, agrees that over the past few years there is an increasing dominance of both local and international companies in the commercial seed sector.
The number of commercial seed companies in Malawi has been increasing since 2005, the year the government rolled out the Input Subsidy Program (IPS). This programme provides subsidised fertiliser and seeds to poor farmers.
With this, the demand for seeds of main crops, such as maize, legumes, sorghum and rice, skyrocketed. To meet the demand, commercial seed companies have been encouraged to take over the process, from production to distribution.
As a result the number of seed companies has increased to 24 from just five in 2005, according to Supply Chisi, business development officer of the Seed Trade Association of Malawi (STAM).
“These companies have overtaken communities by storm with their participation in the subsidy programmes. The companies now have more sovereign power than the locals. This is the new reality,” Ken Machira, an agriculture expert from the Lilongwe University of Agriculture and Natural Resources, told DTE.
Additional reporting by Collins Mtika, Suzgo Chitete and Tikondane Vega in Malawi, Kelvin Mbewe and Newton Sibanda in Zambia, and Felix Mwakyembe in Tanzania.
This is the first in a three-part series. Watch this space.
This was first published in Down To Earth’s print edition (dated 1-15 May, 2022)
We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.